Embroidered Railroad Garments Embroidered Railroad Garments

The Railroad Art Critic

(The views expressed below are the views of Denny Jelsma, and his opinions of artists and art work.)

Jelsma Graphics is one of, if not the largest distributor of railroad art in the country, and has been since 1985. I have seen thousands of pictures of railroad items from prints to original paintings. While some have been extremely good, some have also been very bad. "I feel my knowledge of railroadings historical aspects as well as my understanding the desires of the railfan, is something I can bring to the table to help make an experienced critique." I can bring my knowledge of the RR industry and RR history coupled with the desires of railfans to bear in my honest evaluation of these artists, something that we have been doing quite well for years here at Jelsma Graphics.

We always try to offer only the best art available. We are constantly being asked of our opinions of railroad art, and our opinion has been truly appreciated by the railfans. Because of this, I have decided to come up with a rating system for artists in general, and for railroad prints as well. The criteria we will be using is based on a variety of aspects. We will be scoring the artists with a rating from 1 - 10. "Ten" will be excellent, while "One" will be unacceptable. We will be rating artists on reliability, honesty, timeliness, historical accuracy, style, and salability. The artists that we will be rating, will be artists who's products we carry.

We will also rate each individual print. Even though we may have an artist listed as rated "Nine," that artist may produce a painting that we feel should be rated "Five." We will be rating each individual print to help you decide if this print is a good investment for you.

We will be adding a rating list of original paintings in the very near future. You will be able to find the paintings listed, with their rating listed by them. You will also be able to see the rating number when you click on to the pictures of the paintings. Please see our list of artists below, as we feel they should be rated. Each artists rating below is an average of all the products we carry for that artist. To see individual ratings, click on the artists name, which will link you to the prints database with images and more information on each individual print.

Note that any artist who has not yet been rated is marked "NR" (Not Rated) and is currently under evaluation. As soon as a numerical "Rating" has been established it will be posted. In the meantime, if you feel you need some advise please feel free to call our phone number or send us an email Email Critic

RAILROAD ARTISTS RATING LIST

NAME
OF ARTIST
  JG
AVERAGE RATING

Larry Fisher (41) ........................ 9.2
Lesilie Ragan  .................... 9.0
Biedeman  ............................... 9.0
John Black  .......................... 9.0
William S. Phillips  .......... 9.0
Phil Belbin  ......................... 9.0
Mike Danneman (34) .................... 8.8
John Jordal (6) ......................... 8.5
Robert Hunt (2) ......................... 8.5
Randy Rolffs (11) ........................ 8.3
Erik Hollander (3) ................... 8.3
Tucker Smith (3) ........................ 8.3
John Coker  .......................... 8.0
Bradley W. Shoemaker  ......... 8.0
E. Pelicano  ......................... 8.0
E. J. Petras  ........................ 8.0
M. E. Raulerson (2) .................. 8.0
Harlan Hiney (3) ........................ 8.0
Wabash Rrhs  ......................... 8.0
Mark Harland Johnson (12) ......... 8.0
Don Feight (17) .......................... 8.0
Robert Downs  ........................ 8.0
Russ Porter (70) ......................... 8.0
Joann Kargus  ........................ 8.0
Richard M. Sparks (2) ............... 8.0
Howard Fogg (15) ......................... 8.0
Oleg Stavrowsky  .................. 8.0
H. Suter  ............................... 8.0
Richard Pedersen (10) ................ 7.9
Tony Fachet (51) ......................... 7.8
Gil Reid (44) ............................... 7.8
Donald Reid (21) ......................... 7.6
Tom Rock (11) ............................... 7.6
Jim Jordan (30) .......................... 7.5
Al Chesley (16) .......................... 7.5
David Tutwiler (7) ................... 7.4
Peter A. Lerro Jr. (12) .............. 7.3
Tony Howe (97) .............................. 7.2
Bruce Friesch (20) .................... 7.2
Michael Boss (8) ........................ 7.1
Steve Aitken  ........................ 7.0
Barbara L. Webb (2) .................. 7.0
Ted Xaras  .............................. 7.0
Nrf  ...................... 7.0
Chesley Bonstell  ................ 7.0
Norman Fraser  .................... 7.0
Bill Gardoski (2) .................... 7.0
Arthur A. Johnson  ............... 7.0
E. Krabbenhoft  ................... 7.0
Robert W. Todd (3) ................... 7.0
J. Graig Thorpe (20) .................. 7.0
Elsie Barbee  ........................ 7.0
Jim Herron  .......................... 7.0
Harriet A. Hill (2) .................. 7.0
John Winfield (49) .................... 6.8
Art Olds (18) ............................... 6.6
Robert West (201) ......................... 6.5
James D. Young (2) ................... 6.5
Steven Cryan (2) ........................ 6.5
Tom Daniels (3) ......................... 6.3
Keith Wilkerson (6) .................. 6.2
Ron Hatch (4) .............................. 6.2
Wentworth D. Folkins (4) ......... 6.2
John Bromley (15) ........................ 6.1
Gil Bennett (7) ......................... 6.1
D. Coker (3) ............................... 6.0
Jim Hutton (2) .......................... 6.0
Ron Flanary (3) ......................... 6.0
Eggleston (2) .............................. 6.0
Paul N. Norton  ................... 6.0
Proehl  .................................... 6.0
Andrew Harmantas (2) ................ 6.0
Stan Haring  ......................... 6.0
Richard Schultz (14) .................. 5.9
William Dalmam Jr. (5) .............. 5.8
Marc Desobeau (10) .................... 5.6
Raymond George (2) ................... 5.5
Dean Belowich (3) .................... 5.3
J. B. Mellen (6) ........................ 5.3
Ben Dedek (2) .............................. 5.0
David Kirkland (2) ................... 5.0
Clayborn Dotson (2) .................. 5.0
Alan Farmor  ......................... 5.0
Don R. Ingwersen (4) ................ 5.0
Tony Bullard (2) ........................ 5.0
Charles Maurer  ................... 5.0
Paul A. Meyet  .................... 5.0
F. Carlson (3) .......................... 5.0
Annie Mellen  ........................ 5.0
Ava Howard (7) .......................... 4.7
Shayne Stoakes (6) ................... 4.7
Thos. M. Ward (3) .................... 4.0
Robert Kline (2) ........................ 4.0
Donald Bergan  .................... 4.0
Steve Anderson (3) ................... 3.7
Herb Mott (12) .............................. 3.2
Cindy Neumeyer  ................... 3.0
Unknown (392) ................................ 0.2
Rebel Rails  ......................... NR
Photo  ..................................... NR
N. R. H. S.  ......................... NR
Jelsma Graphics  .................. NR
Bledsoe Rail Slides  .......... NR
E. M. D.  ............................... NR
Denny  ..................................... NR
Michael Del Vecchio  .......... NR
 
Embroidered Railroad Garments